Are YA Books Becoming Less Popular for Youngsters?

I was going to talk about something completely different today, but a little note in something I was reading caught my eye, suggesting that youngsters aged thirteen and fourteen prefer not to read YA books designed for their age group, but prefer, instead, to stick to simpler stories meant for a younger age. The example used was Roald Dahl’s ‘The Twits’.1Z3_the_twits

Of course, as a writer and a teen myself, I was, at first, shocked, then thrown into disbelief. It’s a worrying thought that children are becoming less involved with reading and writing – this Telegraph internet article states that 54% of children in a survey questioned said they preferred watching TV to reading. And, naturally, this must lead to poor comprehensive skills.

It’s true that I, along with other teens I know, sometimes need a break from lengthy, factual or complex books to read something below our level that we probably shouldn’t. Going back to the above example, I might even read a simple Roald Dahl once in a while to remind myself of the plot, or if I got a ‘craving’ for a certain type of book like that.

CLOCKWORKPRINCESSCOVERSPECIAL2-265x400For years, I wanted to follow the plots of series even when I technically grew out of them. On a slightly more advanced level, books like those Cassandra Clare has written. Whilst I’ve never read them myself, I have a friend at a top university who still reads them from time to time because she can.

It happens. We can’t stop teenagers from reading something that they enjoy. And, yes, I do mean this the other way, too. When one delves into the writing community, one finds that the tastes of writers are often more advanced than non-writers. Whilst a 13-year-old friend of mine has read very few classical novels, she has read the entire Shades of Grey trilogy. Please take a moment to despair with me.

On the other hand, the research suggests that the reasons behind teens’ choices are less to do with personal preference and more to do with reading ability. Of course, one can’t enjoy a book that one has trouble understanding. It is this fact which causes me the most anxiety in relation to our society nowadays.

The Internet is an exciting place for teens…
books not so much, as shown by Youtube's TomSka
…books not so much, as shown by Youtube’s TomSka

I am torn whether to believe this is really happening to the next generation or not. I can understand how the internet, especially time-wasting, often-poor-quality sites like Facebook and Tumblr, causes youngsters to disregard literature, especially if it is too long for them to read quickly – but are we really learning (or ‘being conditioned into’ to use the psychological term) a lifestyle of laziness and ill-educated manners?

On the other hand, I believe that the facts focus on the wrong sample of teenagers in the UK. I cannot say how widespread or from where they got their information from, but I can say that many of the teenagers I know do not conform to this statistic in the same way. (Then again, I may myself be providing a biased sample of lower-middle class private-educated thirteen to nineteen year olds).

I’m not a big fan of teen/YA books, but at least if I read, I go for something beyond my settled skills. Putting my own bias to one side even when I say this, I have to say that nearly all the teenagers I know are good readers, even if they are not avid. Obviously, I surround myself with many writer-teens, who, like myself, are actually beginning to write in the NA, nineteen to thirty category. Main protagonist’s age aside, I am assuming that they are using more complex storylines, theories (at one point, one of my protagonists has an argument whether his actions were his own fault or whether he was always going to do them regardless) and vocabulary. NA books contain more than just scenes that one couldn’t put in a teen book.

So. Are teen books becoming less popular for teens?


Two side-notes:

1) My Word of the Week is DEFENESTRATE. Just because I’m no longer doing the segment doesn’t mean I don’t still have words that demand their presence in my mind throughout the week. So, defenestrate: doesn’t that sound so funny? Meaning ‘to throw out or through the window’ (!), it comes from the Latin de (down from) fenestra (window).

2) As I revise for my exams, I intend to take some time away from writing the usual blog posts. But do not despair! If things go to plan, I’ll be creating essays (most Psychology) on the basic facts that I am learning, like repetition in lead for an encoding of ideas.


6 thoughts on “Are YA Books Becoming Less Popular for Youngsters?

  1. This is definitely disheartening…I’m older than you (in my early thirties), but my experiences were so much different than the ones you’re reading about in this article. I was 8 when I picked up my first adult-level book, and by the time I was 13, I stopped reading YA altogether and was reading mainstream and literary adult fiction. I hate to be one of those people that starts sentences with “back in my day,” but, really, back in my day it at least felt like youth was more interested in the classics. I hope these statistics aren’t true, but my gut tells me they are.

    1. I often feel like I should be saying “back in my day” as well, because of how much technology has shaped the course of reading and literature over the last five years or so.
      I admire that you were reading adult books at such a young age. I think it was my lack of access to them that stopped me, but, nowadays, I believe it is due more to the opinions of youngsters. Perhaps it is laziness that stops children reading higher-level books. It’s depressing.
      Thanks for commenting. 🙂

  2. I don’t think teens reading “younger” books is a bad thing in itself. I’m an avid, “advanced” reader, but I still go back to Harry Potter and the Chronicles of Narnia (at age 32, no less), and I devour YA books and the occasional middle-grade fantasy like Fablehaven between “grown-up” novels. Children’s and YA books are fast reads, they’re relaxing, and the focus on story can be refreshing when you’re getting really bored with slogging through Anna Karenina (*ahem*). Also, nostalgia is a big thing. If I’ve fallen in love with a world in the past, I’ll want to go back regardless of the reading level. I don’t feel like I need to prove myself as a reader.

    The thing about it that does bother me is the idea that these teenagers either can’t read more advanced books (due to comprehension issues), or just don’t want to because they’ve never learned to appreciate the depth of enjoyment that comes from digesting a long, satisfying, complex story. That breaks my heart a little. There’s nothing wrong with enjoying a children’s book now and then; the problem is when that’s all you’re capable of. (My husband is a person who can read and comprehend, but doesn’t enjoy reading for pleasure– not children’s or adult books. I’ll never understand it.)

    1. That’s a fair point. Nostalgia is a influencer of a lot of what some people read. I’m myself a big fan of the Skulduggery Pleasant books for the reasons you’ve given: with having to read around my subjects at school and produce essays twice a week, I don’t have time to engross myself in books that aren’t quick, light reads.

      With all the monetary issues in living nowadays, I think it comes down to it that some children are educated to appreciate literature, whilst others are the opposite, unable to make their way through YA books because of the comprehension issues.

      Thanks for posting such a thoughtful comment. 🙂

  3. I purposefully read YA/MG because often “adult” reads are laden with boring details. I’m reading The Wise Man’s Fear, an adult fantasy, and good gracious is it super long with all the politics and other crap. YA/MG characters get to do cool stuff. It probably is some parts reading level, but I think it’s other parts boring book to begin with. *shrug*

Thoughts, comments, replies...

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s